Frequently Asked
Labour Law
Questions
Navigating labour law and human resources can be complex. This FAQ page is designed to provide clear, practical answers to the most common questions we receive from employers, employees and HR professionals.
The FAQs are grouped by our main service areas to help you quickly find relevant information, whether you need guidance on labour law compliance, disciplinary processes, workplace disputes, restructuring, or HR support.
While these answers offer general guidance, every workplace situation is unique. If you require advice specific to your circumstances, we encourage you to contact us for professional assistance.
Book a Consultation
South African Labour Law & Compliance
South African labour law places clear responsibilities on employers and employees. These FAQs address legal obligations, workplace policies, and practical steps to remain compliant with current labour legislation. Explore our Labour Law & Compliance services for detailed support.
Which labour laws must my business comply with in South Africa?
Most employers must comply with the Basic Conditions of Employment Act (BCEA), the Labour Relations Act (LRA), the Employment Equity Act (EEA), and the Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA). Depending on your industry, Sectoral Determinations or Bargaining Council agreements may also apply.
Do I legally need to provide a written employment contract?
Yes. The BCEA requires you to provide employees with specific written particulars of employment (such as job description, hours, and remuneration) when they start working. A written contract protects both parties by clarifying these terms.
What is the maximum number of hours an employee can work per week?
General employees may work up to 45 ordinary hours per week. Overtime is limited to 10 hours per week and must be remunerated at 1.5 times the normal wage or exchanged for time off, by agreement.
How is annual leave calculated under the BCEA?
Employees are entitled to at least 21 consecutive days of annual leave for every annual leave cycle, or one day of leave for every 17 days worked.
Can I deduct money from an employee’s salary for damages or loss?
Only if the employee has agreed to the deduction in writing in respect of a specific debt, or if a court order or arbitration award permits it. You cannot make general deductions without due process and consent.
What is the National Minimum Wage?
The National Minimum Wage changes annually (usually in March). Employers must ensure they pay at least this rate per hour to avoid penalties and CCMA referrals.
Do I have to pay employees during maternity leave?
South African law does not force employers to pay maternity leave unless stated in the employment contract or a collective agreement. However, employees can claim benefits from the Unemployment Insurance Fund (UIF).
What constitutes an "Unfair Labour Practice"?
Unfair labour practices include unfair conduct relating to promotion, demotion, probation, training, or the provision of benefits. It also covers the unfair suspension of an employee or refusal to reinstate an employee under an agreement.
Are fixed-term contracts legal for permanent roles?
Employees earning below a certain threshold may be deemed permanent after 3 months of continuous employment unless the employer can justify the fixed term (e.g., for a specific project or replacing someone on leave).
How do I ensure my business is fully compliant?
We recommend a full Labour Law Compliance Audit. We review your contracts, policies, and procedures to identify risks and ensure alignment with the latest legislation.
How often should a business review its labour documents?
We recommend reviewing your contracts and policies at least annually. However, you should also review them immediately whenever there are amendments to labour legislation or significant changes to your internal company structure.
Can you help with compliance after an audit or inspection?
Yes. If you have received a compliance order or findings from a Department of Labour inspection, we can assist you in resolving the non-compliance issues and guide you through the corrective steps to prevent legal action.
What risks come with non-compliance?
Non-compliance carries significant risks, including severe financial penalties, frequent CCMA disputes, and reputational damage. ensuring early compliance is the most cost-effective way to protect your business and its operations.
Add a Different Question
Disciplinary & Employee Management
Managing employees fairly is essential to maintaining a productive workplace. These FAQs provide guidance on disciplinary procedures, misconduct, incapacity, poor performance, and fair workplace processes. View our Disciplinary & Employee Management services to learn more.
What is the difference between a verbal and a written warning?
A verbal warning is usually for minor, first-time infractions and is valid for a short period (e.g., 3 months). A written warning is more formal, recorded in the personnel file, and used for repeated or more serious misconduct.
When can I dismiss an employee for misconduct?
Dismissal is a last resort reserved for serious misconduct (e.g., theft, gross dishonesty, assault) or repeated offences where progressive discipline (warnings) has failed. It must be substantively and procedurally fair.
Do I always need to hold a disciplinary hearing before dismissal?
Yes. The audi alteram partem principle applies, meaning you must give the employee an opportunity to state their case before a decision is made.
Can an employee have legal representation at an internal disciplinary hearing?
Generally, employees are entitled to representation by a fellow employee or shop steward. Outside legal representation (lawyers) is usually not a right unless your disciplinary code allows it or the case is exceptionally complex.
What happens if an employee refuses to sign a warning?
The employee does not need to sign for the warning to be valid. You should have a witness sign to confirm that the warning was issued and explained to the employee who refused to sign.
How do I handle an employee who is constantly absent?
You should investigate the reasons for absence. If it is medical, it is an incapacity issue. If it is without valid reason, it is misconduct (AWOL/absenteeism) and should be handled via the disciplinary process.
Should an employee always be suspended during an investigation?
Not necessarily. Suspension is a precautionary measure, not a punishment. It must be objectively justified (e.g., fear of interference with witnesses). We guide you on the correct procedure to avoid unfair labour practice claims.
Can I suspend an employee immediately?
Yes, a "precautionary suspension" is allowed if you have a reasonable fear that the employee might interfere with an investigation or witnesses, or cause damage. This suspension must be on full pay.
What is "constructive dismissal"?
This occurs when an employee resigns because the employer made continued employment intolerable. The onus is on the employee to prove that they had no choice but to resign.
How do I manage poor work performance?
Poor performance is treated as incapacity, not misconduct. You must follow a counseling process: identify the problem, offer training/support, give a reasonable time to improve, and hold regular review meetings before considering dismissal.
Does VRS Labour Law Consultants chair disciplinary hearings?
Yes, we provide independent, neutral chairpersons to preside over hearings. This ensures the process is unbiased and procedurally fair, reducing the risk of adverse CCMA findings.
Can you help draft disciplinary charges?
Yes. Incorrectly phrased charges can ruin a case. We assist in drafting charges that are accurate, legally sound, and fully supported by the available evidence to ensure substantive fairness.
Do you handle workplace investigations?
Yes. We conduct impartial and thorough investigations into misconduct, grievances, and sensitive allegations to determine if there are sufficient grounds to proceed to a disciplinary hearing.
Can a hearing be held virtually?
Yes. Remote hearings via video conferencing are now common practice in South Africa. They are fully compliant with labour law, provided they are managed properly to ensure the employee’s right to participate is not compromised.
Add a Different Question
Organisational Change & Restructuring
Workplace changes must be handled carefully and in line with labour law requirements. These FAQs explain retrenchments, restructuring processes, consultation duties, and lawful approaches to organisational change. Learn more about our Organisational Change & Restructuring services.
What is Section 189 of the Labour Relations Act?
Section 189 governs dismissals based on operational requirements (retrenchments). It outlines the legal process employers must follow when they contemplate reducing staff due to economic, technological, or structural needs.
How much notice must I give for a retrenchment consultation?
There is no specific statutory "notice period" to start consultation, but you must issue a Section 189(3) notice as soon as you contemplate retrenchment. The consultation process itself must be meaningful and cannot be rushed.
What is the difference between Section 189 and Section 189A?
Section 189 applies to small-scale retrenchments. Section 189A applies to "large-scale" retrenchments (e.g., retrenching 10 people in a company of 50) and allows for facilitation by the CCMA.
What acts as a fair selection criteria for retrenchment?
LIFO (Last In, First Out) is the most accepted objective criterion. However, you can also use criteria like skills retention, provided it is objective, fair, and agreed upon during consultation.
Must I pay severance pay?
Yes. The statutory minimum is one week’s remuneration for every completed year of continuous service. If a contract or policy states a higher amount, you must pay the higher amount.
Can I retrench employees to hire cheaper labour?
No. Retrenching strictly to replace employees with lower-paid workers doing the exact same job is often viewed as automatically unfair. There must be a genuine economic or structural rationale.
What topics must be discussed during the consultation?
You must attempt to reach consensus on avoiding dismissals, minimising the number of dismissals, the timing, selection criteria, and severance pay.
What happens if a transfer of business takes place (Section 197)?
If a business is transferred as a "going concern," existing employees transfer automatically to the new employer with their service years and conditions of employment intact. They cannot be retrenched solely because of the transfer.
Can VRS Labour Law Consultants facilitate the retrenchment process?
Yes. We guide employers through the entire Section 189 process, drafting the notices, facilitating the consultation meetings, and ensuring all procedural boxes are checked to avoid unfair dismissal claims.
Do I have to pay out accumulated leave during a retrenchment?
Yes. Upon termination of employment (including retrenchment), you must pay out any accrued annual leave that strictly hasn't been taken.
What documentation is required for a Section 189 retrenchment process?
The process requires a formal Section 189(3) Notice, detailed records of all consultation meetings, minutes of discussion, objective selection criteria, and final outcome letters to the affected employees. We assist you in preparing all necessary legal documents.
Can VRS Labour Law Consultants assist employees facing retrenchment?
Yes. While we primarily serve employers, we also offer advice to affected employees regarding their rights, options for settlement, and the correct procedure for referring disputes to the CCMA or Bargaining Council.
Can organisational restructuring lead to disputes?
Absolutely. If the procedural requirements of Section 189 are not followed correctly, the process can result in costly unfair dismissal claims at the CCMA or Labour Court. Proper legal guidance from the start is essential to mitigate this risk.
Add a Different Question
Workplace Dispute Resolution & Representation
Workplace disputes can be complex and time sensitive. These FAQs explain dispute resolution options, CCMA processes, and professional representation for fair outcomes. Visit our Dispute Resolution & Representation services for full details.
What is the CCMA?
The Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) is an independent body that resolves labour disputes. Most unfair dismissal and unfair labour practice disputes are referred here.
Can VRS Labour Law Consultants represent me at the CCMA?
Yes. We are members of a registered Employers’ Organisation, which gives us the right of appearance to represent our clients in arbitration and conciliation proceedings at the CCMA and Bargaining Councils.
What is the time limit for an employee to refer a dispute?
For unfair dismissal, it is 30 days from the date of dismissal. For unfair labour practices, it is 90 days. Late referrals require a "condonation" application.
What is the difference between Conciliation and Arbitration?
Conciliation is a "without prejudice" meeting where a commissioner tries to help parties settle. If no settlement is reached, the matter goes to Arbitration, which is a formal hearing where a commissioner makes a binding decision (award).
What happens if I receive a default award against my company?
If you missed the hearing and a judgment was made against you, you can apply for a "Rescission of Judgment" to have the case re-heard. This must be done quickly and with valid reasons for your absence.
Are CCMA awards binding?
Yes, an arbitration award is final and binding. It can be enforced like a court order. If you are unhappy with the outcome, you can only take it on Review to the Labour Court (not appeal) if there was a defect in the process.
Do I need a lawyer for the CCMA?
Not necessarily. While employees often represent themselves or use unions, employers are advised to use labour law experts (like VRS) to ensure evidence is presented correctly and legal arguments are sound.
What is Con-Arb?
Con-Arb is a process where arbitration immediately follows conciliation if the dispute remains unresolved on the same day. Parties can object to Con-Arb in writing (within specific timeframes) if they want separate dates.
Can I settle a dispute before the hearing?
Yes, parties can sign a settlement agreement at any stage before or during the process. This is often a cost-effective way to manage risk.
Which Bargaining Councils do you cover?
We can assist with disputes in all major Bargaining Councils (e.g., MEIBC, NBCRFLI) provided we have jurisdiction. Contact us to confirm coverage for your specific sector.
Can you help prepare evidence for a CCMA or Bargaining Council hearing?
Yes. We assist in compiling the complete 'bundle of documents,' drafting key witness statements, and preparing the necessary legal arguments for a strong case presentation at arbitration.
Do you negotiate settlements?
Yes. We actively negotiate on your behalf during conciliation or at any stage before arbitration to achieve a fair, practical, and legally sound settlement agreement that minimizes risk and cost.
What if my case was referred late to the CCMA?
CCMA referrals have strict time limits. If you are late, we prepare and submit a formal Condonation Application with strong supporting arguments, asking the Commissioner to excuse the delay and hear your case.
What should I bring to the first consultation?
To ensure we can advise you efficiently, please bring all relevant documents, including the letter of dismissal/dispute, disciplinary records, correspondence between the parties, and a clear, chronological timeline of events.
Add a Different Question
Advisory & Value-Added Services
Ongoing legal and strategic support helps businesses manage risk and remain compliant. These FAQs cover advisory services, legal opinions, compliance support, and practical workplace guidance. Discover our Advisory & Value Added services for tailored assistance.
What are "White-label" services?
This service is designed for law firms or other consultancies. We perform labour law work (such as drafting opinions or contracts) on your behalf, under your brand, allowing you to expand your service offering without hiring internal specialists. Learn more about our White-label Legal Services.
What is the difference between an ad-hoc and a retainer option?
Ad-hoc services are "pay-as-you-go" for specific issues like a single hearing or contract. A retainer involves a fixed monthly fee for ongoing access to advice, document review, and unlimited telephonic support.
Why should I choose a retainer package?
A retainer ensures your costs are predictable and encourages you to seek advice before acting, which prevents costly mistakes. It is like having an in-house labour law department at a fraction of the cost.
Can you audit my current HR policies?
Yes. We review your existing disciplinary codes, leave policies, and contracts to ensure they are legally compliant and practical for your specific operational environment.
Do you offer opinion writing?
Yes. If you have a complex legal scenario, we can research case law and provide a formal written legal opinion on the prospects of success and recommended strategy.
Are your services available remotely?
While we are based in Kempton Park, Gauteng, we assist clients nationally using video conferencing (Zoom/Teams), email, and phone for consultations and advisory work.
Can you help with Criminal and Credit checks?
Yes, we offer background screening services to help you vet potential employees before you hire them, reducing the risk of hiring dishonesty or incompetence.
What is a "mutually agreed separation"?
This is a negotiated exit where the employer and employee agree to part ways on specific financial terms, often used to avoid long disciplinary processes or potential disputes. We can draft these agreements to ensure they are binding.
Do you provide training for managers?
Yes. We offer workshops on how to initiate discipline, how to manage absenteeism, and basic labour law compliance to empower your line managers.
How quickly can I get advice?
Retainer clients typically receive same-day responses. For ad-hoc matters, we aim to schedule a consultation or provide a quote within 24 hours of your enquiry.
Can you assist start-up businesses with labour law compliance?
Absolutely. We specialise in helping new businesses establish legally sound employment contracts, foundational HR policies, and disciplinary structures from day one, ensuring a compliant foundation for growth.
Do you offer comprehensive workplace audits?
Yes. Our value-added services include Labour Law Compliance Audits, HR policy reviews, and risk assessments to proactively identify and mitigate potential liabilities within your operations before they become costly disputes.
Add a Different Question
Human Resources Solutions
Strong HR practices support compliance, performance, and employee engagement. These FAQs address HR processes, documentation, and integrated workforce support. Explore our Human Resources Solutions to see how we can assist.
Do you offer recruitment services?
Through our trusted HR partners, we assist with sourcing candidates, screening CVs, and conducting initial interviews to ensure you find the right fit for your culture and requirements.
Can you assist with UIF registration and claims?
Yes, our HR partners can handle the administrative burden of registering your company for UIF and assisting employees with their claim documentation (e.g., maternity or unemployment).
What is included in your HR Policy Manual?
A comprehensive manual includes policies on sexual harassment, social media usage, grievances, leave, health and safety, and working hours, tailored to your business culture.
Do I need to submit an Employment Equity Report?
If you are a "designated employer" (based on staff turnover or headcount of >50), you must submit annual reports to the Department of Labour. We can assist with the compilation and submission of these plans.
How do I manage employee performance appraisals?
We help design performance management systems (KPIs) that are objective and clear. This makes it easier to reward good performers and legally manage poor performers.
What is Skills Development facilitation?
If your payroll exceeds R500k per annum, you pay a Skills Development Levy (SDL). We can help you submit a Workplace Skills Plan (WSP) to claim back a portion of this levy for training purposes.
What is "onboarding" and why is it important?
Onboarding is the process of integrating a new employee. A structured onboarding (contracts, induction, policy review) ensures the employee settles in quickly and understands the rules from day one.
Can you draft job descriptions?
Yes. Clear job descriptions are vital for performance management. We ensure they accurately reflect the roles and responsibilities required by your operations.
Do you assist with COIDA (Workman’s Compensation)?
Yes, we can assist with registrations and obtaining Letters of Good Standing, which are often required for tenders and contracts.
How does the HR partnership work with VRS?
VRS focuses on the legal compliance (contracts, disputes), while our HR partners focus on the people management (recruitment, training, soft skills). This gives you a complete "one-stop" solution for your workforce.
Can you assist with implementing performance appraisals?
Yes. Through our HR solution partners, we design and facilitate fair, structured performance appraisal processes that are legally defensible, promote employee development, and link directly to performance management.
Do you offer HR documentation templates?
Yes. We provide customisable and legally compliant HR templates, including essential warning letters, employment forms, and core policy documents, to simplify your administrative and compliance burden.
Add a Different Question